Democratizing Research
Community members collect and analyze data in Prof. Colleen Fisher’s study of a youth trauma intervention in Zimbabwe
As a research methodologist with expertise in anti-oppressive and anti-extractive methods, University of Denver Graduate School of Social Work (GSSW) Professor Colleen Fisher works to advance use of bottom-up and participatory approaches to research. Most recently, that has included a two-year, mixed-methods cluster randomized controlled trial of Singing to the Lions (STL), a three-day biopsychosocial intervention designed in Zimbabwe for Zimbabwean youth who had experienced trauma.
Fisher is a global health equity scholar who focuses on the intersection of health, gender, and poverty in low- and middle-income countries and other low-resource contexts. She says, “People have used [Singing to the Lions] all over the world, but there had never been a rigorous evaluation of it. This was the first research to ever formally assess the impact.”
The methods Fisher used also marked another first. She explains, “Typically, when global health researchers say ‘mixed methods,’ what they mean is a quantitative study component paired with semi-structured qualitative interviews or focus groups.” However, Fisher’s team asked a subsample of children who received the intervention to draw themselves and their environment in response to a broad prompt. The team then asked the children to name each person or object they drew, explain how the people or objects related to the prompt, and give their drawing a title. “The drawings themselves, children’s annotations, and their own analysis of their drawings were a central component of our qualitative data.”
The researchers also used the Most Significant Change method, which Fisher says is used extensively in the international development and program evaluation fields but to her knowledge has not been used in social work. “It’s completely participatory, meaning the researcher essentially gets out of the way and invites the community itself to collect and analyze the data.”
Most Significant Change facilitates storytelling to elicit participants’ lived experience with some phenomenon—in this case, to examine intervention impacts from the perspective of parents and caregivers. For the STL study, community members and the research team together determined the domains of change: child attitudes, behaviors, and skills. Community members were trained to conduct two-question 1:1 interviews (N = 50) with parents/caregivers in one rural and one urban community, asking them, “What was the most significant change you observed in your child after they finished the Singing to the Lions workshops?” and “Why do you consider that change the most significant?” Teachers from the classrooms where STL was delivered analyzed the interview transcripts together in small groups; each group then selected five stories of change most salient to the community, sharing them back during an in-person community celebration event.
Fisher notes that methods such as Most Significant Change democratize the research process through participatory data collection and analysis. This strategy can deepen researchers’ understanding of intervention effects from diverse perspectives. At the same time, such methods can empower participants and enhance the relevance and acceptability of research findings for the community.
In Phase 1 of the STL project, over 1,300 young people were randomized by their school to the immediate intervention group or waitlist control group. Demographic characteristics and trauma symptoms were assessed at baseline while intervention outcomes of self-esteem, self-efficacy, hope, self-calming, and social support were assessed at baseline, after the intervention, and again three months later. Phase 2 included the Most Significant Change interviews and children’s drawings.
Fisher notes, “It felt really important to evaluate the intervention using traditional quantitative methods that the international research community would recognize and funders would value so that the community partner would get the data that they need to sustain their efforts. And it also felt really important to pair that approach with participatory qualitative methods that were ultimately selected by the community itself.”
Fisher’s research was conducted in collaboration with NGO Miracle Missions Vimba, University of Zimbabwe education faculty, and funder Catholic Relief Services. The team is now disseminating their work, with the first of five planned manuscripts published in PLOS Mental Health in September 2026. Because dissemination to the local community is as important to Fisher as sharing findings with the scientific community, every time the team writes a paper about the STL study, they partner with a graphic designer from Zimbabwe to create a comic-style one pager in English and Shona (the local language) to make findings accessible for low-literacy and non-research audiences. In May 2026, Fisher presented findings in Santiago, Chile, at the Global Awareness Society International conference and in June 2026, at the Social Work & Social Development conference in Nairobi, Kenya. Fisher will deliver two related methods presentations on “democratizing evidence in social work” and on the Most Significant Change method at the January 2027 Society for Social Work and Research conference.
Fisher says that at their core, methods such as Most Significant Change are “diffusing the power that typically is sourced within the researcher to the community. It’s not really power-sharing; it’s literally shifting power to the community and not just in data collection but in how the data are analyzed and interpreted. “[It aligns] with social work values to elicit perspectives of how the intervention impacts people’s lives, in participants’ own words, using their own frame of reference.”
She continues, “To me, that feels incredibly powerful. We’re very intentionally stepping aside and saying, we want to learn what the community says is important. And we trust that what comes out is going to be just as meaningful and important or maybe more so than what we would have gotten if we would have gone down a typical researcher-led road.”